Dragons, Tigers, and Turtles - Vietnam, Thailand, and the Philippines

Dragons, Tigers, and Turtles: A 25-Year Economic Saga of Vietnam, Thailand, and the Philippines

Over the past 25 years, Vietnam has roared ahead of Thailand and the Philippines, powered by export-led industrialization and foreign direct investment (FDI). The Philippines, fueled by remittances and business process outsourcing (BPO), lags due to infrastructure deficits and governance woes. Thailand, once an ASEAN powerhouse, stumbles under political turmoil and an aging population. Vietnam’s manufacturing dominance contrasts with Thailand’s tourism reliance and the Philippines’ service-driven economy. Geopolitical tensions—China’s sway versus Western ties—shape their futures. By 2035, Vietnam could lead ASEAN, but each faces unique risks in sustaining growth amidst global uncertainties.


Economic Performance Over the Last 25 Years

Key Economic Measures (2000–2025, Every 5 Years)
Using World Bank, IMF, and Asian Development Bank (ADB) data, we track GDP growth (annual %), GDP per capita (PPP, current international $), and FDI inflows (% of GDP). These snapshots reveal stark contrasts.

  • 2000
    • Philippines: GDP growth: 4.4%; GDP per capita: ~$2,500; FDI: 2.1%
      • Call centers sprouted in Manila; agriculture dominated but creaky roads hindered progress.
    • Thailand: GDP growth: 4.8%; GDP per capita: ~$5,000; FDI: 3.5%
      • Post-1997 crisis recovery leaned on tourism and electronics exports.
    • Vietnam: GDP growth: 6.8%; GDP per capita: ~$1,200; FDI: 4.9%
      • Doi Moi reforms ignited garment factories in Hanoi.
    • Quote: “Vietnam’s early 2000s boom was reform-driven,” says Dr. Le Dang Doanh, Vietnamese economist.
  • 2005
    • Philippines: GDP growth: 4.9%; GDP per capita: ~$3,200; FDI: 1.8%
      • BPO giants like Accenture flocked to Cebu; remittances hit $10 billion.
    • Thailand: GDP growth: 4.6%; GDP per capita: ~$6,500; FDI: 3.8%
      • Thaksin’s ousting sparked unrest; Phuket’s beaches thrived.
    • Vietnam: GDP growth: 7.5%; GDP per capita: ~$1,900; FDI: 6.3%
      • WTO entry loomed; Intel invested $1 billion.
    • Quote: “Thailand’s political chaos began dimming its star,” says Dr. Pavida Pananond, Thammasat University.
  • 2010
    • Philippines: GDP growth: 7.6%; GDP per capita: ~$4,100; FDI: 1.2%
      • Post-GFC rebound; remittances cushioned shocks.
    • Thailand: GDP growth: 7.5%; GDP per capita: ~$8,500; FDI: 3.2%
      • Protests rocked Bangkok; exports recovered.
    • Vietnam: GDP growth: 6.4%; GDP per capita: ~$3,100; FDI: 8.1%
      • Samsung’s $1 billion Bac Ninh factory marked Vietnam’s rise.
    • Quote: “Remittances saved the Philippines but limited industrialization,” says Dr. Cielito Habito, Ateneo de Manila.
  • 2015
    • Philippines: GDP growth: 6.2%; GDP per capita: ~$5,400; FDI: 2.0%
      • Aquino’s reforms boosted governance; BPO revenues hit $22 billion.
    • Thailand: GDP growth: 3.0%; GDP per capita: ~$10,200; FDI: 2.8%
      • 2014 coup chilled investment; tourism held firm.
    • Vietnam: GDP growth: 6.7%; GDP per capita: ~$4,800; FDI: 6.1%
      • Electronics exports soared; RCEP talks advanced.
    • Quote: “Vietnam’s FDI magnet status reshaped ASEAN,” says Dr. Nguyen Thi Tue Anh, CIEM.
  • 2020
    • Philippines: GDP growth: -9.5%; GDP per capita: ~$6,800; FDI: 1.9%
      • COVID-19 shuttered BPO offices; remittances dipped 0.8%.
    • Thailand: GDP growth: -6.1%; GDP per capita: ~$12,000; FDI: 1.5%
      • Tourism crashed (6.7 million visitors vs. 40 million in 2019).
    • Vietnam: GDP growth: 2.9%; GDP per capita: ~$7,100; FDI: 5.1%
      • Swift COVID-19 response kept factories humming.
    • Quote: “Vietnam’s pandemic resilience was a global outlier,” says Dr. Vo Tri Thanh, Vietnamese economist.
  • 2025 (Projected)
    • Philippines: GDP growth: 6.0%; GDP per capita: ~$8,500; FDI: 2.5%
      • Marcos’ infrastructure push and CREATE MORE Act spur growth.
    • Thailand: GDP growth: 2.8%; GDP per capita: ~$13,500; FDI: 3.0%
      • Tourism recovers; political risks linger.
    • Vietnam: GDP growth: 6.5%; GDP per capita: ~$9,500; FDI: 6.5%
      • Tech exports drive growth.
    • Quote: “Vietnam’s manufacturing edge is unmatched,” says Rajiv Biswas, S&P Global.

Analysis: Vietnam’s 6-7% growth reflects its manufacturing prowess. The Philippines’ 5-6% growth relies on services, while Thailand’s ~3% highlights structural woes.

Forecast for 2030 and 2035

  • Philippines
    • 2030: GDP growth: 6.1%; GDP: ~$600 billion; GDP per capita: ~$10,000
      • Infrastructure and BPO drive growth; CREATE MORE Act boosts FDI.
    • 2035: GDP growth: 6.0%; GDP: ~$800 billion; GDP per capita: ~$12,000
      • Young workforce fuels potential if infrastructure improves.
    • Quote: “The Philippines’ youth could propel it forward with better roads,” says Jaffar Al-Rikabi, World Bank.
  • Thailand
    • 2030: GDP growth: 3.0%; GDP: ~$650 billion; GDP per capita: ~$15,000
      • Tourism and EEC stabilize growth.
    • 2035: GDP growth: 2.9%; GDP: ~$800 billion; GDP per capita: ~$17,000
      • Aging population caps potential.
    • Quote: “Thailand’s demographics demand productivity gains,” says Dr. Somchai Jitsuchon, TDRI.
  • Vietnam
    • 2030: GDP growth: 6.5%; GDP: ~$750 billion; GDP per capita: ~$12,000
      • Electronics and FTAs drive growth.
    • 2035: GDP growth: 6.2%; GDP: ~$1 trillion; GDP per capita: ~$15,000
      • Could rival Indonesia in ASEAN.
    • Quote: “Vietnam’s supply chain integration ensures sustained growth,” says Dr. Raymond Mallon, World Bank.

Analysis: Vietnam’s export-driven model points to ASEAN leadership. The Philippines needs infrastructure leaps, while Thailand’s growth is constrained.

Economic Strategies and Structural Differences

Philippines

  • Strategy: Service-led growth via BPO and remittances ($40 billion in 2023). “Build, Build, Build” and CREATE MORE Act target infrastructure and FDI.
  • Structural Features: Services (~60% of GDP) dominate, with BPO employing 1.5 million. Agriculture (~10%) is labor-intensive but outdated. Industry (~30%) lags due to poor infrastructure (WEF rank: 96th).
  • Anecdote: In Quezon City, BPO worker Ana juggles night shifts to support her family, but a two-hour commute on clogged roads saps her energy.
  • Evidence: CREATE MORE Act cut corporate taxes to 20%, attracting Google. Manila’s traffic costs $3.5 billion yearly.
  • Quote: “The Philippines’ service economy is resilient but needs industry,” says Dr. Arsenio Balisacan, NEDA.
  • Outside View: “The Philippines’ infrastructure gap is a brake on progress,” says Dr. Linda Lim, University of Michigan.

Thailand

  • Strategy: Tourism and export-led manufacturing; Eastern Economic Corridor (EEC) targets high-tech FDI. Visa-free policies boost visitors.
  • Structural Features: Tourism (~15% of GDP); industry (~35%) includes electronics and autos. Agriculture (~10%) supports rural areas. Aging population (median age ~40) strains labor.
  • Anecdote: Chiang Mai’s hotelier Somsak saw bookings vanish in 2020 but rebound to 80% capacity in 2023, showing tourism’s fragility.
  • Evidence: EEC attracted $20 billion FDI since 2018; 2023 protests deterred investors.
  • Quote: “Thailand’s EEC is bold, but politics undermine it,” says Dr. Aekapol Chongvilaivan, ADB.
  • Outside View: “Thailand’s tourism reliance exposes it to shocks,” says Dr. Meredith Woo, University of Virginia.

Vietnam

  • Strategy: Export-oriented industrialization via FTAs (RCEP, CPTPP) and low-cost labor. FDI in electronics drives growth.
  • Structural Features: Industry (~40%) leads, with electronics ~50% of exports. Agriculture (~15%) modernizes; services (~45%) grow. Young workforce (median age ~32) fuels productivity.
  • Anecdote: In Bac Ninh, factory worker Linh assembles Samsung phones, earning $350/month, symbolizing Vietnam’s export boom.
  • Evidence: 17 FTAs cover 60% of global GDP; exports hit $370 billion in 2023.
  • Quote: “Vietnam’s FTAs make it a manufacturing hub,” says Dr. Suiwah Leung, Australian National University.
  • Outside View: “Vietnam’s export model thrives but leans heavily on China,” says Dr. Yukon Huang, Carnegie Endowment.

Why Philippines Lags Vietnam:

  • Infrastructure: Philippines’ road density (0.3 km/km²) trails Vietnam’s (0.5 km/km²). Traffic costs could hit $6 billion daily by 2030.
  • FDI: Vietnam’s FDI (~6-8% of GDP) dwarfs Philippines’ (~2%). Vietnam’s single-window clearance lures Apple.
  • Governance: Philippines ranks 99th in corruption (CPI 2023) vs. Vietnam’s 83rd.

“Vietnam’s reforms outpace the Philippines’ bureaucracy,” says Dr. Ronald Mendoza, Ateneo de Manila.

Why Thailand is Slowing Down:

  • Politics: Coups (2006, 2014) and 2023 protests scared investors.
  • Demographics: Workforce shrinks 0.5% yearly.
  • Tourism: Pre-COVID, 20% of GDP; 2020 collapse exposed risks.

“Thailand’s political turmoil dims its economic light,” says Dr. Thitinan Pongsudhirak, Chulalongkorn University.

Key Growth Drivers

Philippines

  • Remittances: $40 billion (~10% of GDP) in 2023; nurses and seafarers stabilize consumption.
  • BPO: $30 billion revenue, employing 1.5 million. Firms like Teleperformance thrive.
  • Infrastructure: $160 billion plan (5% of GDP) includes Manila subway.
  • Youth: Median age ~25; 65% working-age by 2030.
  • Anecdote: Cebu’s BPO worker Maria supports five relatives but endures gridlocked commutes.
  • Evidence: BPO grew 10% annually pre-COVID; infrastructure spending up 20% since 2022.
  • Quote: “BPO and remittances anchor the Philippines, but infrastructure is key,” says Dr. Benjamin Diokno, former Finance Secretary.
  • Outside View: “The Philippines’ young workforce is a gem if infrastructure catches up,” says Dr. Dani Rodrik, Harvard University.

Thailand

  • Tourism: $40 billion in 2023 (~15% of GDP); visa-free policies draw 28 million visitors.
  • Electronics: $60 billion in exports (~25%).
  • EEC: Targets $30 billion FDI by 2030 for AI and robotics.
  • Autos: Produces 2 million vehicles yearly.
  • Anecdote: Phuket’s vendor Noi saw tourism revenue plummet in 2020, rebounding in 2023.
  • Evidence: EEC secured $5 billion tech FDI in 2024.
  • Quote: “Tourism and exports drive Thailand, but diversification is critical,” says Dr. Kirida Bhaopichitr, TDRI.
  • Outside View: “Thailand’s auto sector shines, but politics cast a shadow,” says Dr. Alicia Garcia-Herrero, Natixis.

Vietnam

  • FDI: $28 billion in 2023; electronics ~50% of exports ($180 billion).
  • FTAs: RCEP, CPTPP boost trade 15% yearly.
  • Labor Costs: ~$300/month vs. Thailand’s $600.
  • Workforce: 70% working-age.
  • Anecdote: Ho Chi Minh City’s worker Linh earns $350/month at Samsung, fueling exports.
  • Evidence: Exports grew 12% yearly since 2015.
  • Quote: “FDI and FTAs are Vietnam’s growth engines,” says Dr. Adam McCarty, Mekong Economics.
  • Outside View: “Vietnam’s manufacturing boom is stellar but risks over-reliance on FDI,” says Dr. Joseph Stiglitz, Columbia University.

Strengths, Weaknesses, and Risks

Philippines

  • Strengths:
    • Young Population: Median age ~25; 65% working-age by 2030. Could drive consumption and labor growth.
    • BPO Sector: $30 billion revenue; 1.5 million jobs. Resilient to global shocks.
    • Remittances: $40 billion in 2023; cushions economic volatility.
    • English Proficiency: Ranks 20th globally, boosting BPO and education.
  • Weaknesses:
    • Infrastructure: WEF rank 96th; traffic costs $3.5 billion yearly.
    • Governance: Corruption (CPI rank 99th) deters FDI.
    • Inequality: Gini ~0.41; rural poverty persists.
    • Low Industrialization: Industry only 30% of GDP vs. Vietnam’s 40%.
  • Risks:
    • Geopolitical Tensions: South China Sea disputes could disrupt trade with China (~18% of imports).
    • Natural Disasters: Typhoons cost $4 billion yearly, straining budgets.
    • BPO Saturation: Automation and competition from India threaten jobs.
  • Quote: “The Philippines’ youth is a strength, but infrastructure and governance are bottlenecks,” says Zafer Mustafaoğlu, World Bank.

Outside View: “The Philippines risks missing its demographic window without reforms,” says Dr. Amartya Sen, Harvard University.

Thailand

  • Strengths:
    • Tourism: $40 billion in 2023; global brand as a travel hub.
    • Manufacturing: Electronics and autos (~25% of exports) are competitive.
    • EEC: $20 billion FDI since 2018; targets high-tech growth.
    • Infrastructure: WEF rank 60th; better than regional peers.
  • Weaknesses:
    • Political Instability: Coups and protests deter FDI.
    • Aging Population: Workforce shrinks 0.5% yearly; median age ~40.
    • Tourism Reliance: 15% of GDP vulnerable to global shocks.
    • Inequality: Rural-urban divide persists.
  • Risks:
    • Political Volatility: 2023 protests signal ongoing unrest.
    • Demographic Decline: Aging population could cut growth by 1% annually by 2030.
    • Global Slowdowns: Tourism and exports sensitive to demand drops.
  • Quote: “Thailand’s tourism is a jewel, but politics and aging are Achilles’ heels,” says Dr. Somkiat Tangkitvanich, TDRI.

Outside View: “Thailand’s political risks outweigh its economic strengths,” says Dr. Peter Drysdale, Australian National University.

Vietnam

  • Strengths:
    • FDI Magnet: $28 billion in 2023; electronics dominate exports.
    • FTAs: 17 agreements cover 60% of global GDP.
    • Young Workforce: Median age ~32; 70% working-age.
    • Low Costs: $300/month wages attract firms like Foxconn.
  • Weaknesses:
    • China Reliance: $45 billion imports; supply chain risks.
    • Governance: Corruption (CPI rank 83rd) persists.
    • Environment: Industrial pollution threatens sustainability.
    • Education Gaps: Only 30% of workforce has tertiary education.
  • Risks:
    • Geopolitical Tensions: South China Sea disputes could disrupt trade.
    • Over-Reliance on FDI: Electronics sector vulnerable to global shifts.
    • Rising Wages: Labor costs up 10% since 2020, risking competitiveness.
  • Quote: “Vietnam’s FDI-driven model is robust but tied to China,” says Dr. Edmund Malesky, Duke University.

Outside View: “Vietnam’s growth is stellar, but environmental and governance risks loom,” says Dr. Ngaire Woods, Oxford University.

Geopolitical Entanglements

  • Philippines: U.S. ally via EDCA; South China Sea tensions strain China trade.
    • Quote: “The Philippines’ U.S. tilt secures defense but risks trade,” says Dr. Renato Cruz De Castro, DLSU.
  • Thailand: Neutral; balances U.S. and China.
    • Quote: “Thailand’s neutrality preserves trade flexibility,” says Dr. Pavida Pananond.
  • Vietnam: Balances China trade with U.S. ties via “China Plus One.”
    • Quote: “Vietnam navigates U.S.-China tensions skillfully,” says Dr. Le Hong Hiep, ISEAS.

ASEAN Leadership Potential

Vietnam’s growth and FTAs position it to lead ASEAN by 2035. The Philippines’ infrastructure and governance gaps, and Thailand’s political woes, limit their prospects.

  • Quote: “Vietnam could redefine ASEAN’s economic map,” says Dr. Huong Le Thu, International Crisis Group.

Integration with China and the West

  • China: Vietnam’s trade ($45 billion imports) leads; Philippines (~18%) and Thailand (~20%) less integrated.
    • Quote: “Vietnam’s China ties are deep but risky,” says Dr. Shay Wester, Asia Society.
  • West: Philippines leans West (U.S. exports ~15%); Vietnam grows U.S. trade (~16%); Thailand balances.

 “The Philippines’ Western alignment contrasts Vietnam’s pragmatism,” says Dr. Malcolm Cook, ISEAS.

Development and Social Indicators (2023)

  • Philippines: HDI: 0.710; Poverty: 18%; Literacy: 96%; Life Expectancy: 72.
  • Thailand: HDI: 0.803; Poverty: 6%; Literacy: 94%; Life Expectancy: 78.
  • Vietnam: HDI: 0.726; Poverty: 5%; Literacy: 95%; Life Expectancy: 75.

“Vietnam’s social gains are impressive but face governance hurdles,” says Dr. Jonathan Pincus, UNDP.

Conclusions

Vietnam’s manufacturing juggernaut, fueled by FDI and FTAs, positions it as ASEAN’s future leader. The Philippines, with its youthful workforce and BPO strength, could soar if it tackles infrastructure and corruption. Thailand, hobbled by politics and aging, risks fading without bold reforms. Geopolitical tightropes—China’s influence vs. Western ties—shape their paths, with Vietnam balancing deftly, the Philippines leaning West, and Thailand staying neutral. Risks like geopolitical tensions, natural disasters, and global slowdowns loom large, but each nation’s unique strengths offer hope for navigating the turbulent decades ahead.

References

  • World Bank, Economic Indicators, 2025
  • IMF, ASEAN Outlook, 2024
  • ADB, Asian Development Outlook, 2025
  • McKinsey, Southeast Asia Economic Review, 2025
  • Asia Society, China-ASEAN Trade, 2023
  • DOF, Philippines Economy, 2025
  • @spectatorindex, ASEAN Growth, 2024

Comments

Post a Comment

archives

Popular posts from this blog

Feasibility of Indus River Diversion - In short, it is impossible

Image
Himalayan River Systems: An Analysis of River Courses and the Feasibility of Indus River Diversion "Diverting the Indus to the Kashmir Valley is highly infeasible. The significant elevation difference and the Pir Panjal range pose major geographical barriers. The project would require immense engineering efforts and astronomical costs. Furthermore, it would likely cause catastrophic flooding and carries severe geopolitical risks" Executive Summary The Himalayan region is the source of major river systems in South Asia, including the Indus and Jhelum. The Karakoram, Ladakh, and Zanskar ranges significantly influence the courses of the Zanskar, Indus, and Shyok rivers, acting as both barriers and channels. The Indus River originates in Tibet and flows northwest through Ladakh and Gilgit-Baltistan, while the Shyok River originates in the Karakoram and joins the Indus. The Zanskar River originates in the Zanskar Range and also flows into the Indus. The Jhelum River originates...
Read more

IIMA Ventures: Pioneering India’s Innovation Continuum

Image
IIMA Ventures: Pioneering India’s Innovation Continuum Since its inception in 2002, IIMA Ventures, the startup incubator of IIM Ahmedabad, has been a cornerstone of India’s entrepreneurial ecosystem, backing over 700 startups with $16-$18 million in investments. Focused on deep tech, inclusive tech, and climate tech, it has accelerated 1,500+ startups, with successes like Razorpay and Agnikul Cosmos achieving unicorns and IPOs. Portfolio companies have raised over $1 billion, with 15 exits, including acquisitions by Flipkart and Ola. Compared to Y Combinator, Surge, and Antler, IIMA’s academic rigor and regional incubation network stand out, though its smaller funding size is a limitation. Led by Priyanka Agarwal Chopra, IIMA plans to invest in 40-50 startups in 2025 via a ₹40 crore fund with SIDBI. This essay explores IIMA Ventures’ journey, impact, comparisons, and future, highlighting its role in fostering India’s $1 trillion startup economy by 2030 . Essay: IIMA V...
Read more

India’s Ethanol Revolution

Image
India’s Ethanol Revolution: Fueling Energy, Farming, and the Future (2018–2030) Over the past seven years, India’s Ethanol Blending Programme (EBP) has transformed from a modest initiative into a cornerstone of energy and agricultural policy. Ethanol production has soared from 1,880 million liters in 2018–19 to 10,000 million liters in 2024–25, achieving 20% petrol blending (E20) ahead of schedule. The feedstock mix has shifted dramatically, with grain-based ethanol, especially maize, now equaling sugarcane’s share, driven by water concerns and policy incentives. This has saved $12.8 billion in crude oil imports (2014–2022) and boosted farmer incomes by ₹87,558 crore. However, rising maize and sugar prices, water stress, and food security concerns pose challenges. By 2030, India aims for 30% blending (E30), requiring 15,000 million liters, with a focus on second-generation (2G) ethanol. Balancing food and fuel demands will need innovative policies, as the program reshapes India’s ene...
Read more