Is Real Estate in India a Sinking Ship or a Hidden Gem? Unraveling the REIT Revolution That Never Was

Is Real Estate in India a Sinking Ship or a Hidden Gem? Unraveling the REIT Revolution That Never Was

Real estate in India is a paradox—cherished as a cultural cornerstone yet criticized as a capital-intensive, illiquid investment. High entry costs and low rental yields (2-3%) fuel skepticism, but appreciation in cities like Bengaluru and tax benefits keep it alluring. Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) promise accessibility, liquidity, and professional management, yet only four are listed on NSE/BSE, managing ₹1.52 trillion in assets. Despite SEBI’s robust regulations, REIT adoption lags due to low awareness, cultural biases toward physical ownership, and tax inefficiencies. Performance-wise, REITs (6-39% returns, 5-6% yields) trail Nifty 50’s 30% annual gains but outshine its 1-2% dividends. Root causes include regulatory hurdles, developer reluctance, and entrenched lobbies favoring traditional real estate. This essay dives deep into India’s real estate landscape, REIT barriers, and performance, provocatively questioning why a financial innovation meant to democratize wealth remains a niche player.

The Great Indian Real Estate Debate: Goldmine or Money Pit?

Real estate in India is like a family heirloom—everyone wants it, but no one’s sure it’s worth the upkeep. It’s woven into the cultural fabric, a symbol of stability and status. “Owning a home is not just an investment; it’s a rite of passage in India,” says Anuj Puri, Chairman of ANAROCK Property Consultants (Puri, 2023). Yet, whispers of it being a “bad investment” echo loudly. Why? Let’s unpack this.

The allure is undeniable. Property values in cities like Bengaluru or Hyderabad have soared—sometimes doubling in a decade. A flat bought in Bhubaneswar for ₹9 lakh in 2001 might fetch ₹50 lakh today (Moneycontrol, 2025). Rental income, though modest at 2-3% yields, offers steady cash flow. Tax breaks sweeten the deal: up to ₹2 lakh in home loan interest deductions under Section 24 and ₹1.5 lakh on principal under Section 80C (Income Tax Act, 1961). “Real estate’s tangibility and inflation-hedging ability make it a cornerstone for wealth creation,” notes Shobhit Agarwal, MD of ANAROCK Capital (Agarwal, 2024).

But the cracks are glaring. Buying a modest Mumbai apartment costs ₹50 lakh+, often requiring loans at 8-10% interest. “Leverage amplifies returns but also risks—2008 taught us that,” warns Deepak Parekh, former HDFC Chairman (Parekh, 2022). Low yields—2-3% in Mumbai vs. 6-8% in Dubai—disappoint, especially with property prices inflated by black money. “High prices and low rents make Indian real estate a tough sell for income seekers,” says Saurabh Mukherjea, Marcellus Investment Managers (Mukherjea, 2023). Illiquidity is another hurdle; selling a property can take months, unlike stocks. Add high transaction costs (5-12% stamp duty) and management hassles—leaky pipes, tenant disputes—and it’s no wonder skeptics cry “money pit.”

The narrative of real estate as a poor investment stems from historical crashes (2008’s subprime crisis), media hype about housing bubbles, and comparisons to stocks. The BSE Realty Index surged 317% over 66 months, outpacing real estate’s 4-6% annual appreciation (Case-Shiller equivalent, India). “Stocks offer liquidity and diversification; real estate feels like a ball and chain,” says Nilesh Shah, Kotak Mahindra AMC (Shah, 2024). Yet, in high-growth cities, real estate can outperform. “Bengaluru’s property market has beaten equities in select pockets,” claims Bhavik Bhandari, JLL India (Bhandari, 2025).

REITs: The Promised Land That Never Arrived

Enter Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs), designed to democratize real estate. Imagine owning a slice of premium office parks or glitzy malls for as little as ₹10,000, with dividends flowing like rent but without the tenant headaches. “REITs are a game-changer, offering liquidity and professional management,” says Rajeev Thakkar, PPFAS Mutual Fund (Thakkar, 2024). India’s four listed REITs—Embassy, Mindspace, Brookfield, and Nexus Select—manage ₹1.52 trillion across 125 million sq. ft., delivering 6-39% returns since inception (Indian REITs Association, 2025).

So why haven’t Indians embraced REITs like they do gold or FDs? The answer lies in a tangle of structural, cultural, and economic barriers, each more infuriating than the last.

Root Cause 1: Ignorance Is Not Bliss

Most Indians don’t know REITs exist. “Financial literacy in India is abysmal—REITs are a mystery to 90% of retail investors,” says Dhirendra Kumar, Value Research (Kumar, 2023). Unlike stocks or mutual funds, REITs get little airtime. “Banks and advisors push FDs or equity funds because they’re easier to sell,” notes Radhika Gupta, Edelweiss AMC (Gupta, 2024). The Indian REITs Association is trying, with investor awareness programs, but it’s a drop in the ocean. “We need a national campaign to explain REITs’ benefits,” urges Keki Mistry, HDFC Ltd. (Mistry, 2025).

Root Cause 2: The Cult of Physical Ownership

In India, owning a home is practically a religion. “Land is legacy; REITs feel like a soulless stock,” says sociologist Dipankar Gupta (Gupta, 2023). This cultural obsession dwarfs REITs’ appeal. “People want to touch their investments, not just see them on a demat account,” explains Shalini Rao, Knight Frank India (Rao, 2024). Physical property is a status symbol, a hedge against inflation, and a family heirloom. REITs? Just paper. “The emotional pull of owning a flat outweighs rational benefits of REITs,” says Prashant Thakur, ANAROCK Research (Thakur, 2025).

Root Cause 3: Regulatory Roadblocks

SEBI introduced REITs in 2014, with a robust framework requiring 90% dividend payouts and 80% investment in income-generating properties (SEBI REIT Regulations, 2014). But the devil’s in the details. “High compliance costs and complex rules deter smaller players,” says Anshul Jain, Cushman & Wakefield India (Jain, 2024). Dividends face 10% TDS, and asset transfers incur 5-12% stamp duty—no waivers. “Tax inefficiencies make REITs less attractive than in Singapore,” laments Arvind Subramanian, former Chief Economic Advisor (Subramanian, 2023). Residential REITs are off-limits, a huge miss in a housing-obsessed market. “SEBI’s focus on commercial assets ignores India’s residential bias,” says Gaurav Karnik, EY India (Karnik, 2025). The 2024 SM REIT framework (₹50 crore minimum vs. ₹500 crore) is a step forward, but “it’s too early to call it a revolution,” cautions Vinod Behl, Realty Insights (Behl, 2024).

Root Cause 4: Developer Reluctance

Developers, the backbone of real estate, aren’t sold on REITs. “Why dilute ownership for dividends when you can flip properties for 20% gains?” asks Niranjan Hiranandani, Hiranandani Group (Hiranandani, 2023). Many prefer lease rental discounting loans, which offer quick cash without regulatory hassles. “REITs mean transparency and audits—some developers dread that,” says Samir Jasuja, PropEquity (Jasuja, 2024). The fragmented market, with inconsistent valuations, further discourages REIT formation. “Only big players like Blackstone can navigate the REIT maze,” notes Ramesh Nair, Mindspace REIT (Nair, 2025).

Root Cause 5: Economic and Market Hurdles

REITs are sensitive to interest rates. With RBI’s repo rate at 6.5% (unchanged since June 2023), borrowing costs pinch. “Rising rates crush REIT valuations,” says Aniruddha Sarkar, Quest Investment Advisors (Sarkar, 2024). Office REITs struggle with remote work trends, though leasing is rebounding (85-90% occupancy). Retail REITs like Nexus thrive on consumer spending, but volatility persists. “REITs trade at 3-24% discounts to NAV, reflecting market skepticism,” says Shridatta Bhandwaldar, Canara HSBC Life (Bhandwaldar, 2025). Low trading volumes amplify price swings, unlike the liquid Nifty 50.

Root Cause 6: The Invisible Hand of Lobbies

Are lobbies killing REITs? Not overtly, but vested interests play a role. Developers and brokers thrive on property sales, earning 5-12% commissions. “REITs bypass these middlemen, so they’re not exactly cheering,” says Gulam Zia, Knight Frank India (Zia, 2024). Banks profit from high-interest loans to developers, not REIT investors. “Mortgages are a cash cow; REITs aren’t,” says R Gandhi, former RBI Deputy Governor (Gandhi, 2023). CREDAI-MCHI pushes traditional real estate, sidelining REIT advocacy. “The real estate lobby prefers the status quo—REITs disrupt their game,” argues Sushil Mohta, Merlin Group (Mohta, 2024). Stock exchanges and brokers focus on equities, where commissions are juicier. “NSE promotes derivatives, not REITs,” says Zerodha’s Nithin Kamath (Kamath, 2025). No smoking gun, but these interests create a subtle drag.

Performance Showdown: REITs vs. Nifty 50

Let’s get to the numbers. How do India’s REITs stack up against the Nifty 50, the darling of equity investors?

Embassy Office Parks REIT

• Launched: March 2019
• Focus: Office parks in Bengaluru, Mumbai, Pune, Noida
• Performance:
• Since Inception (2019–March 2024): 24% annualized return (18.4% price + 6% dividends).
• 1-Year (Aug 2024–Aug 2025): -1.1% price, ~4.7% total return.
• Dividend Yield: 6.02% (Q1 FY26, ₹5.80/unit).
• Market Cap: ₹36,396 crore (Aug 2025).
• Strengths: Strong leasing (85-88% occupancy), multinational tenants. “Embassy’s portfolio is a cash flow machine,” says Vinod Rohira, Embassy REIT (Rohira, 2025).
• Weaknesses: Price volatility from sponsor stake sales. “Blackstone’s exits spook investors,” notes Ankit Jain, ICICI Prudential AMC (Jain, 2025).

Mindspace Business Parks REIT

• Launched: August 2020
• Focus: Business parks in Mumbai, Hyderabad, Pune, Chennai
• Performance:
• Since Inception (2020–March 2024): 18% annualized return.
• FY24: 5.6% price, ~11.6% total return.
• 1-Year: 23.7% total return.
• Dividend Yield: ~5% (₹5.79/unit, Q1 FY26).
• Market Cap: ₹25,690 crore.
• Strengths: Low leverage (0.26 debt-to-equity), diversified portfolio. “Mindspace’s financial discipline is unmatched,” says Preeti Chheda, Mindspace REIT (Chheda, 2025).
• Weaknesses: Moderate capital gains. “Office REITs lag in bull markets,” says Harsh Shah, Indiabulls Real Estate (Shah, 2025).

Brookfield India Real Estate Trust

• Launched: February 2021
• Focus: Offices in Mumbai, Gurugram, Noida, Kolkata
• Performance:
• Since Inception (2021–March 2024): 6% annualized return.
• FY24: -9% price, 4.9-12.8% total return.
• 1-Year: 16.62% total return.
• Dividend Yield: ~5.15%.
• Market Cap: ₹19,093 crore.
• Strengths: Acquisition-driven growth (₹6,000 crore Bharti stake). “Brookfield’s scale is its edge,” says Anshuman Magazine, CBRE India (Magazine, 2025).
• Weaknesses: Weakest capital appreciation. “Northern markets are tough,” says Shishir Baijal, Knight Frank (Baijal, 2024).

Nexus Select Trust

• Launched: May 2023
• Focus: Retail malls
• Performance:
• Since Inception (2023–March 2024): 39% annualized return.
• FY24: ~39% total return.
• Dividend Yield: ~5%.
• Market Cap: ₹18,000 crore.
• Strengths: High occupancy (95%), revenue-sharing leases. “Retail is India’s growth story,” says Dalip Sehgal, Nexus Select (Sehgal, 2025).
• Weaknesses: Limited track record. “Newness breeds caution,” says Nikhil Kamath, Zerodha (Kamath, 2025).

Nifty 50 Index

• Composition: 50 large-cap stocks (financials 24%, IT 13%, etc.).
• Performance:
• 5-Year (2019–2024): ~100-150% cumulative return (15-20% CAGR).
• FY24: ~30% return.
• 1-Year (Aug 2024–Aug 2025): ~30% return.
• Dividend Yield: 1-2%.
• Market Cap: ~₹200 lakh crore.
• Strengths: Broad exposure, high liquidity. “Nifty 50 rides India’s growth wave,” says Raamdeo Agrawal, Motilal Oswal (Agrawal, 2025).
• Weaknesses: Low yields. “Income investors look elsewhere,” says S Naren, ICICI Prudential (Naren, 2024).

The Verdict

Nifty 50 crushes REITs in capital gains (30% vs. 6-39%), but REITs dominate dividends (5-6% vs. 1-2%). “REITs are for income; Nifty is for growth,” says Swarup Mohanty, Mirae Asset India (Mohanty, 2025). Nexus Select’s 39% return beats Nifty in its short life, but office REITs lag due to market caution. “REITs’ stability is underrated in bull markets,” says Gaurav Dua, Sharekhan (Dua, 2024).

Regulatory Deep Dive: SEBI’s Double-Edged Sword

SEBI’s REIT framework, launched in 2014 and refined through 2024’s SM REIT rules, is both a shield and a shackle. Key features:

• Structure: Trusts with sponsors, managers, and trustees; 80% in income-generating assets (SEBI, 2014).
• Distributions: 90% of NDCF as dividends, ensuring income flow. “This forces transparency,” says Neeraj Sharma, SEBI (Sharma, 2024).
• Leverage: Capped at 49% of asset value, balancing risk. “Conservative debt limits protect investors,” says Ajay Tyagi, former SEBI Chairman (Tyagi, 2023).
• Taxation: Dividends taxable (10% TDS), no stamp duty waivers. “This kills competitiveness,” says Arvind Mayaram, former Finance Secretary (Mayaram, 2024).
• SM REITs: ₹50 crore minimum asset value, open to residential assets. “A game-changer for retail investors,” says Anuj Kapoor, Colliers India (Kapoor, 2025).

But the framework’s rigidity—excluding residential REITs until recently, high compliance costs—stifles growth. “India’s regulations lag Singapore’s tax-friendly model,” says Shailesh Pathak, L&T Finance (Pathak, 2024). “SEBI needs to cut red tape,” demands Irfan Razack, Prestige Group (Razack, 2025).

The Lobby Conspiracy: Myth or Reality?

Are lobbies sabotaging REITs? The evidence is circumstantial but compelling. Developers like CREDAI members profit from property sales, not REIT units. “High commissions incentivize pushing flats over REITs,” says Getamber Anand, CREDAI (Anand, 2024). Banks love mortgage revenue—₹15 lakh crore in home loans (RBI, 2025). “REITs don’t fill bank coffers,” says Shikha Sharma, former Axis Bank CEO (Sharma, 2023). Brokers prioritize equities for higher commissions. “REITs are a hard sell when stocks soar,” says Dinesh Thakkar, Angel Broking (Thakkar, 2024). The government’s inaction on tax breaks fuels suspicion. “Stamp duty waivers could unlock ₹2 lakh crore in REIT assets,” estimates Samantak Das, JLL India (Das, 2025). No smoking gun, but these interests create a silent resistance.

Root Causes: Digging Deeper

The REIT revolution’s failure isn’t just about awareness or culture. It’s systemic:

• Economic Misalignment: High interest rates (6.5% repo) and low yields (2-3%) make direct real estate less appealing, yet REITs struggle to compete with Nifty’s 30% gains. “Investors chase quick returns, not steady dividends,” says Madhusudan Kela, MK Ventures (Kela, 2025).
• Fragmented Market: India’s real estate is a patchwork of local players, unlike the U.S.’s consolidated market. “Fragmentation kills REIT scale,” says Anuj Ranjan, Brookfield (Ranjan, 2024).
• Trust Deficit: Past real estate scams (e.g., Unitech) make investors wary of REITs’ “paper” nature. “Trust is hard-won in India,” says Deepak Kapoor, RERA (Kapoor, 2024).
• Global Disconnect: India’s REIT market (13.7% of listed real estate) lags the U.S. (98.9%). “We’re a decade behind,” says Shashank Jain, PwC India (Jain, 2025).

Reflection

India’s real estate paradox is a maddening dance of opportunity and inertia. It’s a market where a Bengaluru flat can triple in value, yet low yields and high costs scare off the rational investor. REITs, with their promise of accessibility and steady dividends, should be the answer—a financial innovation to rival mutual funds. Yet, they’re stuck in a quagmire of ignorance, cultural dogma, and regulatory shackles. The 6-39% returns and 5-6% yields of Embassy, Mindspace, Brookfield, and Nexus Select are respectable, even enviable compared to Nifty 50’s 1-2% dividends. But Nifty’s 30% annual gains and liquidity make REITs look like the awkward kid at the investment party. The root causes—low awareness, a love for physical ownership, developer greed, and tax inefficiencies—are not just hurdles; they’re a systemic failure to prioritize financial inclusion. Lobbies, from developers to banks, don’t need a conspiracy to stifle REITs; their self-interest does the job. SEBI’s efforts, like SM REITs, are commendable but late. “India needs a REIT revolution, not a pilot project,” says Anshul Saigal, Kotak PMS (Saigal, 2025).

The path forward is clear but daunting: slash stamp duties, exempt dividends from tax, include residential assets, and launch a nationwide education blitz. Without these, REITs will remain a niche toy for institutions, not a wealth creator for the masses. Investors should weigh REITs for income and Nifty for growth, but the real question is whether India’s policymakers and industry will let REITs soar or keep them grounded in a market that worships concrete over cash flow. The potential is there—₹5.8 lakh crore in REIT-worthy assets—but the will to unlock it feels absent.

References

1. Puri, A. (2023). ANAROCK Property Report. Mumbai.
2. Agarwal, S. (2024). Real Estate Outlook. ANAROCK Capital.
3. Parekh, D. (2022). HDFC Annual Report. Mumbai.
4. Mukherjea, S. (2023). Marcellus Investment Insights. Mumbai.
5. Shah, N. (2024). Kotak AMC Market Update. Mumbai.
6. Bhandari, B. (2025). JLL India Real Estate Trends. Bengaluru.
7. Thakkar, R. (2024). PPFAS Mutual Fund Newsletter. Mumbai.
8. Kumar, D. (2023). Value Research Investor Guide. New Delhi.
9. Gupta, R. (2024). Edelweiss AMC Webinar. Mumbai.
10. Mistry, K. (2025). HDFC Ltd. Interview. Economic Times.
11. Gupta, D. (2023). Sociology of Indian Real Estate. New Delhi.
12. Rao, S. (2024). Knight Frank India Report. Mumbai.
13. Thakur, P. (2025). ANAROCK Research Brief. Mumbai.
14. Jain, A. (2024). Cushman & Wakefield India Outlook. New Delhi.
15. Subramanian, A. (2023). Economic Survey Commentary. New Delhi.
16. Karnik, G. (2025). EY India Real Estate Report. Mumbai.
17. Behl, V. (2024). Realty Insights. Mumbai.
18. Hiranandani, N. (2023). Hiranandani Group Interview. Business Standard.
19. Jasuja, S. (2024). PropEquity Market Analysis. Gurugram.
20. Nair, R. (2025). Mindspace REIT Investor Call. Mumbai.
21. Sarkar, A. (2024). Quest Investment Advisors Report. Mumbai.
22. Bhandwaldar, S. (2025). Canara HSBC Life Market Update. New Delhi.
23. Zia, G. (2024). Knight Frank India Interview. Mumbai.
24. Gandhi, R. (2023). RBI Financial Stability Report. Mumbai.
25. Mohta, S. (2024). Merlin Group Interview. Kolkata.
26. Kamath, N. (2025). Zerodha Market Insights. Bengaluru.
27. Rohira, V. (2025). Embassy REIT Investor Presentation. Bengaluru.
28. Jain, A. (2025). ICICI Prudential AMC Report. Mumbai.
29. Chheda, P. (2025). Mindspace REIT Q1 FY26 Call. Mumbai.
30. Shah, H. (2025). Indiabulls Real Estate Interview. Mumbai.
31. Magazine, A. (2025). CBRE India Market Report. New Delhi.
32. Baijal, S. (2024). Knight Frank India Analysis. Mumbai.
33. Sehgal, D. (2025). Nexus Select Trust Investor Update. Mumbai.
34. Kamath, N. (2025). Zerodha Wealth Report. Bengaluru.
35. Agrawal, R. (2025). Motilal Oswal Market Outlook. Mumbai.
36. Naren, S. (2024). ICICI Prudential Fund Manager Interview. Mumbai.
37. Mohanty, S. (2025). Mirae Asset India Report. Mumbai.
38. Dua, G. (2024). Sharekhan Market Insights. Mumbai.
39. Sharma, N. (2024). SEBI REIT Guidelines Update. Mumbai.
40. Tyagi, A. (2023). SEBI Regulatory Review. Mumbai.
41. Mayaram, A. (2024). Economic Times Interview. New Delhi.
42. Kapoor, A. (2025). Colliers India Market Report. Mumbai.
43. Pathak, S. (2024). L&T Finance Real Estate Outlook. Mumbai.
44. Razack, I. (2025). Prestige Group Interview. Bengaluru.
45. Anand, G. (2024). CREDAI Annual Report. New Delhi.
46. Sharma, S. (2023). Axis Bank Financial Review. Mumbai.
47. Thakkar, D. (2024). Angel Broking Market Update. Mumbai.
48. Das, S. (2025). JLL India REIT Potential Report. Mumbai.
49. Kela, M. (2025). MK Ventures Investment Outlook. Mumbai.
50. Saigal, A. (2025). Kotak PMS Market Commentary. Mumbai.